RESEARCH to PRACTICE
Fitness for Reducing Osteoporosis
Colleen Christmas, MD
THE PHYSICIAN AND SPORTSMEDICINE - VOL 28 - NO. 10 - OCTOBER 2000
The incidence and prevalence of osteoporosis and fractures increase substantially with age in both women and men (1), such that one in five women older than age 50 has osteoporosis (2). This translates to nearly 1.5 million fractures of all types attributable to osteoporosis each year in the United States, a total that exacts an astounding toll on healthcare costs. Postfracture outcomes are also disappointing. Less than one third of those who fracture their hip recover sufficiently to do basic and instrumental activities of life (3). Many become dependent on others for their care. Finally, the mortality rate of those with hip fractures from osteoporosis is higher than that of their unaffected peers (4).
The bleak outcomes and the threat of dependence instill a deep fear of osteoporosis in many older Americans. Preventing osteoporosis and fractures, then, is a critical component of the quality of life for the growing population of older Americans. Osteoporosis is one of the physical activity-related concerns from other focus areas in the Healthy People 2010 report. Recent research has examined the impact of exercise on limiting osteoporosis, falls, and functional debility in older individuals.
Activities to Mitigate Osteoporosis
Patient activities. In addition to an adequate calcium intake, weight-bearing exercises are a key component of any program to reduce the loss of bone mass associated with menopause and aging. Walking programs (5) and resistance exercises (6) have demonstrated improvements in bone mineral density in older women, while resistance exercises (7), tai chi, and other forms of exercise (8) have been shown to reduce falls. Further research is warranted to delineate the most efficient modality and duration of exercise to reduce osteoporosis and fractures, and also to motivate and enhance compliance with a fitness regimen in older individuals. For many, suggestions to reduce sedentary behavior and begin a simple walking program will be acceptable. Patients can start with an achievable goal such as 10 minutes of walking a day, with progression to 30 minutes a day of cumulative exercise on most days of the week. The type of exercise is probably less important than finding a program to which the patient will adhere.
Physician advice. Perhaps the most important steps physicians can take are to discuss the risks of osteoporosis and its potential sequelae and to explain how exercise can reduce these risks. The primary care provider is in the best position to do this, but other opportunities may arise. For example, physicians may caution patients when densitometry reveals weakening of bones or when they notice that patients have become less active. Most women with kyphosis and a height loss of more than 1.5 in. will have osteoporosis and should be counseled appropriately. Physicians may also explain benefits of exercise when treating patients who are recovering from a hip fracture (remember, they have another hip!). A physician's stern recommendation can motivate patients to take their physical fitness seriously and begin a more healthy lifestyle. To emphasize this, the clinician may give the patient a recommendation written on a prescription pad.
Addressing barriers. It is helpful to obtain a history from patients about their lifelong exercise patterns and interests, and to elicit perceived barriers to exercise. Here, strategies to overcome any barriers can be addressed and the prescription tailored to patient preferences and health concerns. In addition, this should be documented in the medical record to serve as a baseline for follow-up discussions.
Progress and barriers should be readdressed periodically to enhance compliance and to make adjustments when life situations change. Being aware of resources available to the community can be helpful. Such resources may include senior centers, malls that open before hours for walking, and exercise facilities that offer senior discounts on exercise specials and personal trainers familiar with geriatric patients.
Exercise resources. The local chapter of the Arthritis Foundation can often help identify exercise facilities that are affordable to many. Web sites of the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgery (www.aaos.org) and the National Osteoporosis Foundation (www.nof.org) have easy-to-read patient education pages that can be distributed to patients in the office. A guide to addressing exercise with older patients has recently been published (9). It presents an overview of the benefits of exercise for this group and gives tips on how to prescribe and monitor exercise.
New research must focus on what exercise regimen and types are the best for arresting or preventing osteoporosis. Exercise can improve bone strength and reduce falls, but factors to motivate and enhance compliance—with exercise in older individuals and with counseling in physicians—also need further examination. Finally, with the burgeoning elderly population, delineation of the most effective forms of exercise to reduce the various consequences of osteoporosis, such as fractures, pain, and dependency, are imperative to guide clinical care of the frail elderly.
Dr Christmas is an assistant professor in the division of geriatric medicine at Johns Hopkins University and the Johns Hopkins Geriatric Center in Baltimore. Address correspondence to Colleen Christmas, MD, Johns Hopkins Geriatric Center, 5505 Hopkins Bayview Cir, Baltimore, MD 21224; e-mail to [email protected].